Important Case Laws for UGC NET Exam: Your Comprehensive Guide!

Author : Shashwat Srivastava

Updated On : November 21, 2023

SHARE

Reader's Digest: Curious about the landmark cases that every UGC NET aspirant should know? Dive into our guide that simplifies these cases for you. Trust me, you won't want to miss this insightful roundup. Keep reading!

The UGC NET (University Grants Commission National Eligibility Test) exam is a reputed test in India for postgraduate candidates aspiring for a career in research or lectureship.

Within its vast syllabus, the understanding of legal jurisprudence plays a vital role. Specifically, having knowledge of the important case laws for UGC NET exam provides a deep insight into the Indian legal system.

This article aims to provide a clear understanding of some of these important case laws for UGC NET exam from the past few years. So let's begin!

Key Contents

  1. Understanding the UGC NET Exam: An insight into the significance of this esteemed examination in India.
  2. The Significance of Case Laws: Understand what case laws mean and their importance in shaping the legal landscape.
  3. Key Case Laws: A brief overview of some recent important case laws for UGC NET exam that have reshaped jurisprudence.
  4. Effective Study Methods: Practical tips and strategies on how to approach, interpret, and remember these important case laws for the UGC NET exam.
  5. Strategies for Success: Concise advice on note-making, use of mnemonic devices, and interactive study methods to grasp these case laws better.

Download FREE Study Material for UGC NET Law by LegalEdge

 The Significance of Case Laws 

Understanding Case Laws:

  • At its core, case law refers to the decisions made by higher judiciary bodies.
  • These decisions, also known as judicial precedents, serve as guiding principles for subsequent cases of similar nature.

Why are they so pivotal in the Indian Legal System?

  • Foundational Pillars: Just like how the Constitution is a primary document, case laws form the very foundation of the legal structure. They interpret, question, and even challenge written statutes.

  • Dynamic Evolution:

    • Legal textbooks provide static information. However, the law is dynamic and constantly evolving. Case laws showcase this change.
    • For instance, while the Indian Constitution might not have explicitly mentioned the Right to Privacy, the judgment in the case of Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs Union Of India in 2017 declared it as a fundamental right. This reflects the living and adaptable nature of law.
  • Establishing Clarity:

    • Sometimes, statutes can be ambiguous. Through case laws, courts can clarify the meaning and application of certain provisions.
    • Take, for example, the interpretation of 'life' in Article 21 of the Constitution. Over the years, its meaning has been expanded and enriched by various judgments, each adding depth to the concept.

Importance for UGC NET Aspirants:

  • Competitive Edge:

    • While most aspirants might focus on standard legal materials, a thorough understanding of the important case laws for UGC NET exam can make one stand out.
    • It’s not just about knowing the case but understanding the underlying principles and its significance in the legal spectrum.
  • Grasping the Practical Aspect:

    • Legal studies isn't just theory. By studying important case laws for UGC NET exam, aspirants get to see the practical application of the laws they've learned.
    • For example, knowing the principles of Tort law is one thing, but understanding its application in landmark cases like the M.C. Mehta vs Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak Case) adds another layer of comprehension.

 Key Case Laws to Know for UGC NET Law 2023 

1. Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022

 One of the important case laws is the Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022. This landmark judgment dives deep into the essence of the right to a speedy trial.

  • Background: The essence of this case revolved around the plea for bail based on the delay in the trial process.

  • Bench: Justices NV Ramana, Surya Kant, and Aniruddha Bose presided over the case.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Section 43D (5) of UAPA: The main point of contention was whether this section of the UAPA restricts courts from granting bail.
    • Article 21 of the Constitution: It ensures every citizen's right to a speedy trial.
  • Verdict: The apex court confirmed that the Constitutional Courts could grant bail if there's a violation of the Fundamental Right to Speedy Trial.


2. Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021

Diving into the sphere of disability rights, Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021 is another case that features on the list of important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case questioned the UPSC's stand regarding the entitlement of extra time for candidates with disabilities during exams.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016: The primary law that mandates equal opportunities and full participation for people with disabilities.
    • Section 32: Emphasizes on ensuring all educational institutions provide inclusive education to children with disabilities.
  • Verdict: The court reinforced the rights of persons with disabilities, emphasizing the necessity of ensuring them equal rights, especially in competitive exams.


3. V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu 

The matter of how disabilities factor into eligibility criteria for jobs, especially judicial ones, was at the heart of the V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu case.

  • Background: The issue revolved around whether a person with a visual impairment, above a certain degree, can be allowed to hold judicial positions.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016: While the Act itself is geared towards the protection of rights, it does provide for certain relaxations in special scenarios.
  • Verdict: The court held that for the job of a judicial officer, possessing a reasonable limit of faculties was vital. Thus, a limit of 50% visual impairment was deemed a legitimate restriction.


4. Dr. Jaishree Laxmanrao Patil v. Chief Minister 2021

One of the more contemporary and important case laws for UGC NET exam is the Dr. Jaishree Laxmanrao Patil v. Chief Minister 2021, which centered around the contentious issue of reservation.

  • Background: The primary discussion in this case revolved around the Maratha quota in Maharashtra that aimed to provide reservation benefits beyond the constitutionally accepted limit.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • 102nd Amendment of the Constitution: This amendment granted constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC).
    • Article 15(4) and Article 16(4) of the Constitution: These deal with the provision of reservation for backward classes in educational institutions and government jobs respectively.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court struck down the Maratha quota, asserting that it violated the 50% ceiling on reservations, established to ensure a balance between equality and social justice.


5. Madras Bar Association v. Union of India 2021

Reforms in the judiciary and tribunals are always a point of interest, and this case stands out among important case laws for UGC NET exam because of its implications on tribunal structures.

  • Background: The focal point was the validity and implications of certain provisions in the Tribunals Reforms Ordinance 2021.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Tribunals Reforms Ordinance 2021: The bone of contention was whether the reforms proposed in this ordinance stood in line with the principles of justice and fair representation.
    • Article 323A and Article 323B of the Constitution: These deal with the power of Parliament to establish administrative tribunals.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court rendered specific provisions of the ordinance invalid, thereby emphasizing the need for checks and balances in judicial reforms.


6. Neil Aurelio Nunes v. Union of India, 2022

Reservation in educational institutes has always been a hotbed for debate, and the Neil Aurelio Nunes v. Union of India, 2022, adds a fresh perspective, making it essential among important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The challenge was against certain reservation policies in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) for medical courses.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 15(5) of the Constitution: Allows for special provisions by the state for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes or for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in relation to admissions to educational institutions.
  • Verdict: The court emphasized the harmonious coexistence of reservation and merit, ensuring that while social justice is achieved, meritocracy isn't entirely compromised.


7. Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police; 2021

Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police holds a special place on the list of important case laws for UGC NET exam due to its focus on the nuances of public protests.

  • Background: This case arises from the tensions between exercising the democratic right to protest and ensuring that public order remains undisturbed.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 19(1)(a): Protects the right to freedom of speech and expression.
    • Article 19(1)(b): Guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms.
    • Article 19(2) & 19(3): Allow reasonable restrictions on these rights for ensuring public order.
  • Verdict: The apex court emphasized that while the right to protest is a fundamental right, it should not hamper public order or rights of others. The balance between these two is pivotal.


8. Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh; 2021

Dwelling on the crucial intersection of gender and the legal framework, the Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh case emerges as one of the important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case sought to address the way courts handle matters related to sexual crimes and gender sensitization.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 15: Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
    • Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty, which encompasses a life of dignity.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court laid down guidelines ensuring sensitivity while addressing sexual crimes. They emphasized that the legal fraternity needs to be gender-sensitive to ensure justice.


9. Patricia Mukhim v. State of Meghalaya & Ors.; Citation: LL 2021

Positioned at the heart of the freedom of speech debate, this case is a standout among important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: Journalist Patricia Mukhim's writings led to an FIR against her, putting a spotlight on the boundaries of freedom of speech.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 19(1)(a): Protects the freedom of speech and expression.
    • Article 19(2): Puts reasonable restrictions on the aforementioned right for public order, defamation, etc.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court quashed the FIR against Mukhim, emphasizing that citizens have the right to freedom of speech and expressing dissent is a part of a healthy democracy.


10. Mohammad Salimullah v. Union Of India; 2021

Navigating the realm of deportation and individual rights, the Mohammad Salimullah v. Union Of India case becomes pivotal for those exploring important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case spotlighted the proposed deportation of Rohingya refugees and their rights under the Indian Constitution.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty.
    • Article 14: Guarantees equality before the law.
  • Verdict: The court laid emphasis on upholding the rights of individuals, especially when it concerns their fundamental rights under the Constitution, even if they are non-citizens.

 How to Study these Case Laws for UGC NET Exam 

Approaching the important case laws for UGC NET exam is crucial. The technique with which you address these case laws can significantly influence your grasp and eventual performance in the exam. Let's break down the methods to simplify your journey:

1. Importance of Contextual Learning:

Every case law is rooted in a unique socio-political milieu. It’s crucial to delve deep into this background to grasp the real essence of the case.

  • Backdrop Understanding: Before diving into the important case laws for UGC NET exam, ensure you grasp the socio-political situation of the time.

    • Example: A case law addressing freedom of speech might be influenced by political unrest or specific events where speech was curtailed.
  • Historical Connect: Some case laws might be influenced by past events or scenarios, making it crucial to understand historical precedents.

2. Summarizing the Facts:

Given the detailed nature of judgments, it's essential to break them down.

  • Brevity is Key: While studying important case laws for UGC NET exam, jot down concise points that capture the essence of the judgment.

    • Example: If a judgment has ten pages detailing a decision, try to summarize it in ten bullet points or less.
  • Focus on the Outcome: The result or the final decision is often the crux of the case law. Make sure it's clearly outlined in your summary.

3. Connecting the Dots:

Case laws are interlinked in the grand scheme of the legal system.

  • Timeline Creation: Create a timeline of related case laws to see how one judgment influences the next.

    • Example: If a 1990 case law set a precedent, check how it influenced or was referenced in a 2000 case law.
  • Impact Assessment: Understand how a specific case law has impacted or changed existing legal norms or standards.

4. Interactive Study Methods:

Making the study process engaging can help in better retention and understanding.

  • Group Discussions: Discussing important case laws with peers can provide diverse perspectives and deeper insights.

  • Mock Court Sessions: Simulating court scenarios where one can argue for or against a judgment helps in practical understanding.

    • Example: Take the case of “XYZ vs. The State”. One can play the role of the defense, another as the prosecution, and others can be the jury or judges.
  • Debates: Set up debates around the pros and cons of specific judgments. This sharpens analytical thinking and offers a comprehensive understanding.

5. Staying Updated:

The legal domain is dynamic, with new judgments shaping the landscape.

  • Regular Reading: Dedicate time daily or weekly to catch up on recent judgments, especially those that might be considered important case laws for UGC NET exam in the future.

  • Follow Legal Blogs or Platforms: Many online platforms provide summarized and easy-to-understand versions of recent judgments.

    • Example: Websites like LiveLaw or Bar & Bench offer insights into recent legal developments.

 Strategies and Tips! 

1. Make Concise Notes

  • Purpose: The essence of studying important case laws for UGC NET exam lies in understanding and remembering key aspects of each judgment.
    • Example: For the case law “Shreya Singhal v. Union of India”, instead of writing pages about the entire judgment, note down: “Section 66A of IT Act - unconstitutional as it violates freedom of speech.”
  • Tips:
    • Use keywords or phrases that capture the essence.
    • Use different colors or highlighters to emphasize significant points.
    • Keep these notes handy and revisit them regularly.

2. Employ Mnemonic Devices

  • Purpose: Mnemonics are memory aids that can simplify case laws, especially when trying to remember intricate details or complex judgments.

    • Example: For the “Right to Privacy” case (Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India), you might use: “Justice K.P = Keep Private” to remember the crux of the case.
  • Tips:

    • Create rhymes or short stories around the case law names.
    • Associate case laws with familiar images or concepts.
    • The more unique and personal the mnemonic, the easier it is to recall.

3. Test Your Knowledge Regularly

  • Purpose: Regular assessment ensures that your understanding and memory of the important case laws remain sharp.

    • Example: After studying 5-10 case laws, set up a mini-quiz to test recall. Questions could be like, “Which case law dealt with online freedom of speech?”
  • Tips:

    • Organize group discussions. Discussing with peers can often highlight points you might have missed.
    • Use online platforms like Quizlet to create and share quizzes on case laws.
    • Engage in flashcard practices. One side with the case name, and the other with its summary.

4. Always Be Open to Seeking Guidance

  • Purpose: No one has all the answers. Leveraging the knowledge and expertise of others can solidify your understanding of important case laws for UGC NET exam.

    • Example: While studying the “Aadhaar Case”, if you're uncertain about its implications on privacy rights, you might join a forum or online class that explains this aspect.
  • Tips:

    • Participate in webinars or workshops dedicated to UGC NET's legal segment.
    • Join online communities or forums where aspirants discuss and debate case laws.
    • Follow prominent legal educators or mentors online; they often share insights and analyses that can be beneficial.

 Key Takeaways 

  • Case Laws' Vital Role: In the UGC NET exam, understanding case laws is not just a necessity, it's a game-changer. They play a pivotal role in shaping the Indian legal landscape.

  • Studying Strategy: Delve into the background of each case, summarize the facts, relate judgments, and keep the study interactive. Context and connection are king.

  • Stay Updated: The legal realm constantly evolves. Regular reading and updates on new judgments are essential.

  • Engage and Discuss: Turn your learning interactive. Engage in discussions, debates, and mock scenarios to solidify your understanding.

  • Preparation is Key: Arm yourself with concise notes, mnemonic aids, and regular testing to ensure you're ready to tackle the important case laws for UGC NET exam.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022?

Why is Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021 a key case for UGC NET exam?

What restriction did the V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu case bring about?

Which case invalidated the Maratha quota?

How does Madras Bar Association v. Union of India 2021 impact tribunals?

Which case emphasized the balance between reservation and merit in educational institutions?

Why is Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police; 2021 essential for UGC NET exam aspirants?

What did the Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh; 2021 case focus on?

Important Case Laws for UGC NET Exam: Your Comprehensive Guide!

Author : Shashwat Srivastava

November 21, 2023

SHARE

Reader's Digest: Curious about the landmark cases that every UGC NET aspirant should know? Dive into our guide that simplifies these cases for you. Trust me, you won't want to miss this insightful roundup. Keep reading!

The UGC NET (University Grants Commission National Eligibility Test) exam is a reputed test in India for postgraduate candidates aspiring for a career in research or lectureship.

Within its vast syllabus, the understanding of legal jurisprudence plays a vital role. Specifically, having knowledge of the important case laws for UGC NET exam provides a deep insight into the Indian legal system.

This article aims to provide a clear understanding of some of these important case laws for UGC NET exam from the past few years. So let's begin!

Key Contents

  1. Understanding the UGC NET Exam: An insight into the significance of this esteemed examination in India.
  2. The Significance of Case Laws: Understand what case laws mean and their importance in shaping the legal landscape.
  3. Key Case Laws: A brief overview of some recent important case laws for UGC NET exam that have reshaped jurisprudence.
  4. Effective Study Methods: Practical tips and strategies on how to approach, interpret, and remember these important case laws for the UGC NET exam.
  5. Strategies for Success: Concise advice on note-making, use of mnemonic devices, and interactive study methods to grasp these case laws better.

Download FREE Study Material for UGC NET Law by LegalEdge

 The Significance of Case Laws 

Understanding Case Laws:

  • At its core, case law refers to the decisions made by higher judiciary bodies.
  • These decisions, also known as judicial precedents, serve as guiding principles for subsequent cases of similar nature.

Why are they so pivotal in the Indian Legal System?

  • Foundational Pillars: Just like how the Constitution is a primary document, case laws form the very foundation of the legal structure. They interpret, question, and even challenge written statutes.

  • Dynamic Evolution:

    • Legal textbooks provide static information. However, the law is dynamic and constantly evolving. Case laws showcase this change.
    • For instance, while the Indian Constitution might not have explicitly mentioned the Right to Privacy, the judgment in the case of Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs Union Of India in 2017 declared it as a fundamental right. This reflects the living and adaptable nature of law.
  • Establishing Clarity:

    • Sometimes, statutes can be ambiguous. Through case laws, courts can clarify the meaning and application of certain provisions.
    • Take, for example, the interpretation of 'life' in Article 21 of the Constitution. Over the years, its meaning has been expanded and enriched by various judgments, each adding depth to the concept.

Importance for UGC NET Aspirants:

  • Competitive Edge:

    • While most aspirants might focus on standard legal materials, a thorough understanding of the important case laws for UGC NET exam can make one stand out.
    • It’s not just about knowing the case but understanding the underlying principles and its significance in the legal spectrum.
  • Grasping the Practical Aspect:

    • Legal studies isn't just theory. By studying important case laws for UGC NET exam, aspirants get to see the practical application of the laws they've learned.
    • For example, knowing the principles of Tort law is one thing, but understanding its application in landmark cases like the M.C. Mehta vs Union of India (Oleum Gas Leak Case) adds another layer of comprehension.

 Key Case Laws to Know for UGC NET Law 2023 

1. Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022

 One of the important case laws is the Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022. This landmark judgment dives deep into the essence of the right to a speedy trial.

  • Background: The essence of this case revolved around the plea for bail based on the delay in the trial process.

  • Bench: Justices NV Ramana, Surya Kant, and Aniruddha Bose presided over the case.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Section 43D (5) of UAPA: The main point of contention was whether this section of the UAPA restricts courts from granting bail.
    • Article 21 of the Constitution: It ensures every citizen's right to a speedy trial.
  • Verdict: The apex court confirmed that the Constitutional Courts could grant bail if there's a violation of the Fundamental Right to Speedy Trial.


2. Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021

Diving into the sphere of disability rights, Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021 is another case that features on the list of important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case questioned the UPSC's stand regarding the entitlement of extra time for candidates with disabilities during exams.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016: The primary law that mandates equal opportunities and full participation for people with disabilities.
    • Section 32: Emphasizes on ensuring all educational institutions provide inclusive education to children with disabilities.
  • Verdict: The court reinforced the rights of persons with disabilities, emphasizing the necessity of ensuring them equal rights, especially in competitive exams.


3. V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu 

The matter of how disabilities factor into eligibility criteria for jobs, especially judicial ones, was at the heart of the V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu case.

  • Background: The issue revolved around whether a person with a visual impairment, above a certain degree, can be allowed to hold judicial positions.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016: While the Act itself is geared towards the protection of rights, it does provide for certain relaxations in special scenarios.
  • Verdict: The court held that for the job of a judicial officer, possessing a reasonable limit of faculties was vital. Thus, a limit of 50% visual impairment was deemed a legitimate restriction.


4. Dr. Jaishree Laxmanrao Patil v. Chief Minister 2021

One of the more contemporary and important case laws for UGC NET exam is the Dr. Jaishree Laxmanrao Patil v. Chief Minister 2021, which centered around the contentious issue of reservation.

  • Background: The primary discussion in this case revolved around the Maratha quota in Maharashtra that aimed to provide reservation benefits beyond the constitutionally accepted limit.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • 102nd Amendment of the Constitution: This amendment granted constitutional status to the National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC).
    • Article 15(4) and Article 16(4) of the Constitution: These deal with the provision of reservation for backward classes in educational institutions and government jobs respectively.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court struck down the Maratha quota, asserting that it violated the 50% ceiling on reservations, established to ensure a balance between equality and social justice.


5. Madras Bar Association v. Union of India 2021

Reforms in the judiciary and tribunals are always a point of interest, and this case stands out among important case laws for UGC NET exam because of its implications on tribunal structures.

  • Background: The focal point was the validity and implications of certain provisions in the Tribunals Reforms Ordinance 2021.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Tribunals Reforms Ordinance 2021: The bone of contention was whether the reforms proposed in this ordinance stood in line with the principles of justice and fair representation.
    • Article 323A and Article 323B of the Constitution: These deal with the power of Parliament to establish administrative tribunals.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court rendered specific provisions of the ordinance invalid, thereby emphasizing the need for checks and balances in judicial reforms.


6. Neil Aurelio Nunes v. Union of India, 2022

Reservation in educational institutes has always been a hotbed for debate, and the Neil Aurelio Nunes v. Union of India, 2022, adds a fresh perspective, making it essential among important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The challenge was against certain reservation policies in the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET) for medical courses.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 15(5) of the Constitution: Allows for special provisions by the state for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes or for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in relation to admissions to educational institutions.
  • Verdict: The court emphasized the harmonious coexistence of reservation and merit, ensuring that while social justice is achieved, meritocracy isn't entirely compromised.


7. Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police; 2021

Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police holds a special place on the list of important case laws for UGC NET exam due to its focus on the nuances of public protests.

  • Background: This case arises from the tensions between exercising the democratic right to protest and ensuring that public order remains undisturbed.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 19(1)(a): Protects the right to freedom of speech and expression.
    • Article 19(1)(b): Guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms.
    • Article 19(2) & 19(3): Allow reasonable restrictions on these rights for ensuring public order.
  • Verdict: The apex court emphasized that while the right to protest is a fundamental right, it should not hamper public order or rights of others. The balance between these two is pivotal.


8. Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh; 2021

Dwelling on the crucial intersection of gender and the legal framework, the Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh case emerges as one of the important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case sought to address the way courts handle matters related to sexual crimes and gender sensitization.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 15: Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
    • Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty, which encompasses a life of dignity.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court laid down guidelines ensuring sensitivity while addressing sexual crimes. They emphasized that the legal fraternity needs to be gender-sensitive to ensure justice.


9. Patricia Mukhim v. State of Meghalaya & Ors.; Citation: LL 2021

Positioned at the heart of the freedom of speech debate, this case is a standout among important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: Journalist Patricia Mukhim's writings led to an FIR against her, putting a spotlight on the boundaries of freedom of speech.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 19(1)(a): Protects the freedom of speech and expression.
    • Article 19(2): Puts reasonable restrictions on the aforementioned right for public order, defamation, etc.
  • Verdict: The Supreme Court quashed the FIR against Mukhim, emphasizing that citizens have the right to freedom of speech and expressing dissent is a part of a healthy democracy.


10. Mohammad Salimullah v. Union Of India; 2021

Navigating the realm of deportation and individual rights, the Mohammad Salimullah v. Union Of India case becomes pivotal for those exploring important case laws for UGC NET exam.

  • Background: The case spotlighted the proposed deportation of Rohingya refugees and their rights under the Indian Constitution.

  • Provisions Touched Upon:

    • Article 21: Right to life and personal liberty.
    • Article 14: Guarantees equality before the law.
  • Verdict: The court laid emphasis on upholding the rights of individuals, especially when it concerns their fundamental rights under the Constitution, even if they are non-citizens.

 How to Study these Case Laws for UGC NET Exam 

Approaching the important case laws for UGC NET exam is crucial. The technique with which you address these case laws can significantly influence your grasp and eventual performance in the exam. Let's break down the methods to simplify your journey:

1. Importance of Contextual Learning:

Every case law is rooted in a unique socio-political milieu. It’s crucial to delve deep into this background to grasp the real essence of the case.

  • Backdrop Understanding: Before diving into the important case laws for UGC NET exam, ensure you grasp the socio-political situation of the time.

    • Example: A case law addressing freedom of speech might be influenced by political unrest or specific events where speech was curtailed.
  • Historical Connect: Some case laws might be influenced by past events or scenarios, making it crucial to understand historical precedents.

2. Summarizing the Facts:

Given the detailed nature of judgments, it's essential to break them down.

  • Brevity is Key: While studying important case laws for UGC NET exam, jot down concise points that capture the essence of the judgment.

    • Example: If a judgment has ten pages detailing a decision, try to summarize it in ten bullet points or less.
  • Focus on the Outcome: The result or the final decision is often the crux of the case law. Make sure it's clearly outlined in your summary.

3. Connecting the Dots:

Case laws are interlinked in the grand scheme of the legal system.

  • Timeline Creation: Create a timeline of related case laws to see how one judgment influences the next.

    • Example: If a 1990 case law set a precedent, check how it influenced or was referenced in a 2000 case law.
  • Impact Assessment: Understand how a specific case law has impacted or changed existing legal norms or standards.

4. Interactive Study Methods:

Making the study process engaging can help in better retention and understanding.

  • Group Discussions: Discussing important case laws with peers can provide diverse perspectives and deeper insights.

  • Mock Court Sessions: Simulating court scenarios where one can argue for or against a judgment helps in practical understanding.

    • Example: Take the case of “XYZ vs. The State”. One can play the role of the defense, another as the prosecution, and others can be the jury or judges.
  • Debates: Set up debates around the pros and cons of specific judgments. This sharpens analytical thinking and offers a comprehensive understanding.

5. Staying Updated:

The legal domain is dynamic, with new judgments shaping the landscape.

  • Regular Reading: Dedicate time daily or weekly to catch up on recent judgments, especially those that might be considered important case laws for UGC NET exam in the future.

  • Follow Legal Blogs or Platforms: Many online platforms provide summarized and easy-to-understand versions of recent judgments.

    • Example: Websites like LiveLaw or Bar & Bench offer insights into recent legal developments.

 Strategies and Tips! 

1. Make Concise Notes

  • Purpose: The essence of studying important case laws for UGC NET exam lies in understanding and remembering key aspects of each judgment.
    • Example: For the case law “Shreya Singhal v. Union of India”, instead of writing pages about the entire judgment, note down: “Section 66A of IT Act - unconstitutional as it violates freedom of speech.”
  • Tips:
    • Use keywords or phrases that capture the essence.
    • Use different colors or highlighters to emphasize significant points.
    • Keep these notes handy and revisit them regularly.

2. Employ Mnemonic Devices

  • Purpose: Mnemonics are memory aids that can simplify case laws, especially when trying to remember intricate details or complex judgments.

    • Example: For the “Right to Privacy” case (Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India), you might use: “Justice K.P = Keep Private” to remember the crux of the case.
  • Tips:

    • Create rhymes or short stories around the case law names.
    • Associate case laws with familiar images or concepts.
    • The more unique and personal the mnemonic, the easier it is to recall.

3. Test Your Knowledge Regularly

  • Purpose: Regular assessment ensures that your understanding and memory of the important case laws remain sharp.

    • Example: After studying 5-10 case laws, set up a mini-quiz to test recall. Questions could be like, “Which case law dealt with online freedom of speech?”
  • Tips:

    • Organize group discussions. Discussing with peers can often highlight points you might have missed.
    • Use online platforms like Quizlet to create and share quizzes on case laws.
    • Engage in flashcard practices. One side with the case name, and the other with its summary.

4. Always Be Open to Seeking Guidance

  • Purpose: No one has all the answers. Leveraging the knowledge and expertise of others can solidify your understanding of important case laws for UGC NET exam.

    • Example: While studying the “Aadhaar Case”, if you're uncertain about its implications on privacy rights, you might join a forum or online class that explains this aspect.
  • Tips:

    • Participate in webinars or workshops dedicated to UGC NET's legal segment.
    • Join online communities or forums where aspirants discuss and debate case laws.
    • Follow prominent legal educators or mentors online; they often share insights and analyses that can be beneficial.

 Key Takeaways 

  • Case Laws' Vital Role: In the UGC NET exam, understanding case laws is not just a necessity, it's a game-changer. They play a pivotal role in shaping the Indian legal landscape.

  • Studying Strategy: Delve into the background of each case, summarize the facts, relate judgments, and keep the study interactive. Context and connection are king.

  • Stay Updated: The legal realm constantly evolves. Regular reading and updates on new judgments are essential.

  • Engage and Discuss: Turn your learning interactive. Engage in discussions, debates, and mock scenarios to solidify your understanding.

  • Preparation is Key: Arm yourself with concise notes, mnemonic aids, and regular testing to ensure you're ready to tackle the important case laws for UGC NET exam.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of Union of India v. KA Najeeb 2022?

Why is Vikash Kumar v. UPSC 2021 a key case for UGC NET exam?

What restriction did the V Surendra Mohan v. State of Tamil Nadu case bring about?

Which case invalidated the Maratha quota?

How does Madras Bar Association v. Union of India 2021 impact tribunals?

Which case emphasized the balance between reservation and merit in educational institutions?

Why is Kaniz Fatima v. Commissioner of Police; 2021 essential for UGC NET exam aspirants?

What did the Aparna Bhat v. State of Madhya Pradesh; 2021 case focus on?

ABOUT TOP RANKERS

Toprankers, launched in 2016, is India’s most preferred digital counselling & preparation platform for careers beyond engineering & medicine. We envision to build awareness and increase the success rate for lucrative career options after 12th. We offer best learning practices and end-to-end support to every student preparing for management, humanities, law, judiciary & design entrances.

E

: support@toprankers.com

P

: +91-7676564400

Social Channels

App Badge

Chat to Toprankers Team